Repository navigation
Consider moving to a PEP665 compliant build and packaging tool #93
Description
Activity
I believe Poetry is working towards support in Poetry 2.0.
Depending on your needs, Hatch and PDM are probably the next most popular workflow tools.
Reacted by Dev MukherjeeReacted by Dev MukherjeeSee Switching to Hatch by @oliverandrich
I found this issue linked via hatch and figured I'd drop in with a shameless plug (hope you don't mind 😃) for my hatch plugin, hatch-pip-compile.
It enables lockfile support for hatch via pip-compile or uv and has allowed hatch to be a complete one-stop-shop for all my Python project management needs. If you're considering hatch but uncertain about its lack of lockfile support hatch-pip-compile might just be what you're waiting for. Cheers!
Reacted by Dev Mukherjee and WisI found this issue linked via hatch and figured I'd drop in with a shameless plug (hope you don't mind 😃) for my hatch plugin, hatch-pip-compile.
It enables lockfile support for hatch via pip-compile or uv and has allowed hatch to be a complete one-stop-shop for all my Python project management needs. If you're considering hatch but uncertain about its lack of lockfile support hatch-pip-compile might just be what you're waiting for. Cheers!
Hey @juftin thanks for the shameless plug 😄
I started doing an initial migration to
hatchon another project to judge the viability and indeed whathatch-pip-compilemade me shelve the idea for a while.Found your blog post and will study the tool and hopefully it tips us over to move to
hatch.Thanks for taking the time to comment on this issue.
Is your feature request related to a problem? Please describe.
We've been using
poetryas our package management tool which works well for all our needs. Initially I had wondered what other major projects used for package management (moving fromsetuptoolsin theprestansdays).Looking under the hood of projects like
fastapiI found they all use hatch.@brettcannon started the issue Interested in supporting PEP 665? on the repository and it would seem that there are major design variations which would it difficult to make
poetrycompatible withpep665(note that there's mention of the work being sponsored)The python packaging site refers to
hatchquite strongly.Describe the solution you'd like
We should thoroughly read through the packaging guide to ensure we have the right structures and flows.
We should identify if
poetryis still a suitable tool for the requirements, and if not what is and why?We should then produce:
Dockerfilefor building the packages for development and productionDescribe alternatives you've considered
NA
Additional context
See the Python packaging guide.