Repository navigation
docs(operations): allow CNCF Case Study as adopter interview substitute - #2282
Conversation
ae2f719 to
f01b57f
Compare
Extends the adopter interview substitution guidance (cncf#2256) so a published CNCF Case Study, in addition to a published TAB Reference Architecture, may serve in place of an individual adopter interview. It is at the TOC member's discretion who is leading the Due Diligence for Moving Levels to determine whether the Reference Architecture or Case Study meets the necessary standards and includes the information the Due Diligence requires. Signed-off-by: Karena Angell <karena.angell@gmail.com>
f01b57f to
4c8c2c3
Compare
|
Looks good overall; I have one requested change before merge. |
…udy substitutes Address jrsapi review on cncf#2282: apply the same independence check used for interview participants when a Reference Architecture or Case Study substitutes for an adopter interview, so the evidence reflects an independent organization's operational use rather than the project team's or a vendor's account. Signed-off-by: Karena Angell <karena.angell@gmail.com>
|
Thanks @jrsapi - good catch. I've added your suggested language so the same independence check applies to substitutes:
Pushed in 527d08b. I also mirrored it to the contribute-site guide and the announcement blog (cncf/contribute-site#397) to keep the two in sync. |
Per review feedback, remove the first two sentences of the Reference Architecture or Case Study substitution note. They qualified the content rather than being content, and read as abstract in the full guide. The note now opens directly with what may substitute for an adopter interview. Signed-off-by: Karena Angell <karena.angell@gmail.com>
|
merging per @brandtkeller and @jrsapi lgtm |
Summary
Extends the adopter interview substitution guidance added in #2256 (now merged) so that both a published TAB Reference Architecture and a published CNCF Case Study may serve in place of an individual adopter interview.
Adds that it is at the TOC sponsor's discretion during the Due Diligence to determine whether the Reference Architecture or Case Study meets the necessary standards and includes the requisite information the Due Diligence requires to determine whether the project meets the requirements of the level in process.
Changes
operations/dd-toc-guide.md: updated the substitution note in the Conducting Adopter Interviews section to cover Case Studies alongside Reference Architectures, and to state the sponsor-discretion standard.Test plan